Skip to main content

Should I File an Auto Insurance Claim?

A middle-age Caucasian staring at a dent in her car asking herself Should I file an auto insurance claim.

So you’ve had a minor accident. It happens to most of us, sooner or later. You might be a bit shaken up and wondering what to do next. Your first priority, of course, is making sure everyone involved is okay. If there are other drivers, be sure to exchange auto insurance information, whether or not you think it’s necessary. The next step is to take photos of damage to all vehicles involved, the scene of the accident, and any property damage. Now you’re probably asking yourself, “Should I file an auto insurance claim?”

When Not To File An Auto Insurance Claim

There are certain situations when it may not be advisable to file an auto insurance claim. For example, if the cost of the damages is lower than your deductible, it may not be worth it to file a claim as you would end up paying for the damages out of pocket anyway. Additionally, if you have a minor accident that only causes cosmetic damage, it may be more cost-effective to pay for the repairs yourself rather than filing a claim and potentially having your premiums increase. Freeway Insurance, a popular auto insurance provider, offers a range of coverage options to help protect you financially in case of an accident or other unforeseen events on the road. They also have knowledgeable agents who can help you determine the best course of action in situations when filing a claim may not be the best option. 

Situations When Not to File An Auto Insurance Claim

1. Minor accidents with no injuries or significant damage

In certain situations, it may be wise not to file an auto insurance claim, especially when the accident is minor and there are no injuries or significant damage involved. Filing a claim for a small dent or scratch that costs less than your deductible to fix could result in a higher premium or even a loss of your no-claims bonus. Additionally, if the accident was caused by your own mistake, you may want to consider paying for the repairs out of pocket rather than submitting a claim. It’s essential to weigh the pros and cons of filing an auto insurance claim before doing so, as it can impact your future coverage and rates.

2. When the cost of repairs is less than the deductible

There are situations when it may not be wise to file an auto insurance claim, and one of those is when the cost of repairs is less than the deductible. In such cases, it may be more cost-effective to pay for the repairs out of pocket rather than filing a claim. This is because filing a claim for a minor repair can cause your insurance premium to increase in the future, which can end up costing you more in the long run. Additionally, filing a claim for a small amount can also affect your claims history, making it harder to get affordable coverage in the future. It is important to consider these factors and weigh the cost of repairs against your deductible before deciding whether to file a claim or not. 

3. When the at-fault driver is willing to pay for damages out of pocket

In such cases, filing a claim may result in a higher premium, which could end up costing more in the long run than the damages incurred. Additionally, filing a claim may not be necessary if the damages are minor and the cost of repairs falls within the deductible amount. However, it is important to ensure that the at-fault driver provides adequate compensation for the damages and to obtain a written agreement stating the terms of the payment. It’s also important to keep in mind that if there is any uncertainty about the extent of the damages or if there are any injuries, it is always better to file a claim and let the insurance company handle the situation.  

4. When the accident was caused by the policyholder’s negligence

Filing a claim in such circumstances may lead to an increase in the policyholder’s insurance premiums or even the cancellation of their policy altogether. Moreover, if the cost of the damages is relatively low, it may be more cost-effective for the policyholder to pay for the repairs out of pocket rather than involving their insurance company. However, if there were other parties involved in the accident or if there were injuries sustained, it may be necessary to file a claim even if the policyholder was at fault. Ultimately, it is essential to weigh the potential benefits and drawbacks before deciding whether or not to file an auto insurance claim in any given situation.

5. When the policyholder’s insurance rates may increase significantly due to filing a claim

For example, if the damage to the car is minor and the repair cost is close to or less than the policyholder’s deductible, it may be more cost-effective to pay for the repairs out of pocket rather than filing a claim. Additionally, if the policyholder has a history of filing claims, they may want to consider the potential long-term impact on their insurance rates before filing another claim. In some cases, it may be more beneficial to pay for the damages without involving the insurance company to avoid any increase in premiums. Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to file an insurance claim will depend on the specific circumstances of the situation, and policyholders should carefully weigh the costs and benefits before making a decision. 

A not uncommon occurrence with fender-benders is for the drivers to work out a cash arrangement and avoid insurance companies entirely. While this can work out fine, it is risky and generally not recommended. Say you rear-ended someone and from all appearances there is only minor damage that you can pay for out-of-pocket. But then a few days later, the other driver discovers more damage or realizes she is injured – being sued is now a real possibility. You are better off reporting the accident to your insurance company right away.

When to File a Claim

While no one wants their rates to go up, you have an insurance policy for a reason and there are times you should use it. Below are some examples:

  • Another vehicle was involved – You will not always be aware of the extent of the damage or how much it will cost to fix. There could also be injuries that are not obvious at the time of the accident. File a claim any time there’s another driver involved. 
  • There are injuries – Generally, if you’re hurt, you should file a claim. If others are hurt, report it to your insurer immediately to protect yourself from lawsuits.
  • Your policy includes “accident forgiveness” – This is offered by some companies, and if it’s part of your policy, your rates won’t go up for an accident. Just know that if you use this benefit for a minor accident, you won’t have it available if you get into something more serious later.

The Claims Process

Filing auto insurance claims is something no one looks forward to, but when it’s time, it helps to know a bit about the insurance claim process. Your first step will be to contact your insurer or insurance agent and provide any information you’re asked for. Any photos or other documentation you have should be provided as well, as it can greatly assist in claims processing.

A claims adjuster will then investigate the accident to determine who’s at fault and how much you will receive. That includes looking over your car to determine the cost for repairs. Then you’ll take your vehicle to get it repaired at the repair shop of your choice, and the insurance company will either pay you or pay the shop directly.

Accident claims are an unfortunate part of life for many drivers, but hopefully they are a rare occurrence for you. Knowing when you don’t need to file them and when you absolutely should will ensure that you don’t get hit with rate increases when you didn’t need to, and protect your bank account when you do have a claim.

How To Choose The Correct Type Of Insurance 

Freeway Insurance offers a variety of insurance options for drivers, including liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage. Liability insurance provides coverage for damages or injuries caused by the insured driver to other people or their property. Collision insurance covers the cost of repairs or replacement of the insured vehicle in the event of an accident with another vehicle or object. Comprehensive insurance covers damage to the insured vehicle caused by factors such as theft, vandalism, or natural disasters.

There are some situations when it may not be necessary to file an auto insurance claim. For instance, if the cost of repairs is lower than the deductible, it may be more cost-effective to pay for the repairs out of pocket. Additionally, if the damage is minor and doesn’t affect the safety or functionality of the vehicle, filing a claim may not be necessary. In some cases, it may also be beneficial to avoid filing a claim if it would result in a significant increase in insurance premiums. Ultimately, it’s important to weigh the potential benefits and drawbacks of filing an insurance claim before making a decision. 

Importance of Choosing a Reputable Insurance Provider like Freeway Insurance

Choosing a reputable insurance provider like Freeway Insurance is crucial, especially when you find yourself in a situation where you’re unsure whether or not to file an auto insurance claim. A reputable insurance provider will have knowledgeable and helpful staff who can guide you through the decision-making process, explaining the benefits and drawbacks of filing a claim. They can also advise you on the potential impact on your insurance premiums and deductibles. By choosing a reputable insurance provider, you can be confident that you’ll receive accurate and reliable information to help you make an informed decision, ultimately saving you time and money in the long run.

Are you overpaying for auto insurance? Get a free auto insurance quote online or over the phone at 800-777-5620 and find out how much you can save by switching to Freeway Insurance. Freeway lets you compare rates from multiple auto insurance companies to help you find the best coverage at the best price. You can visit any of our locations and our experts will help you!

Ready to Get a Quick Quote?