How to Shop for Car Insurance
-
Written by Ashley Walrath
Ashley Walrath
Content Writer- 10+ Years of Marketing and Content Writing Experience
- Bachelor of Arts in Marketing
Ashley Walrath is a Content Writer at Confie, the parent company of Freeway Insurance, where she creates educational content that helps consumers better understand insurance and make informed coverage decisions. She develops consumer…
Edited by Mónica Alarcón- 10 Years of Content Writing Experience
- 5 Years of Insurance Content Experience
Mónica Alarcón is a bilingual Senior Copywriter at Confie, the parent company of Freeway Insurance, where she specializes in creating educational insurance…
Reviewed by Rose Carter- 13 Years of Insurance Industry and Content Experience
- B.S. in Applied Technology and Performance Improvement, University of North Texas
Rose Carter is an insurance content strategist and marketing executive with 13 years of experience developing consumer-focused insurance education and digital…
Shopping for car insurance can feel overwhelming, especially if you’ve been with the same insurance company for years or aren’t sure what coverage you need. With different rates, deductibles, discounts, and policy options available, knowing what to compare can make the process easier.
Whether you’re buying your first policy or considering switching insurance companies, these steps can help you find coverage that fits your needs and budget.
Key Takeaways
- Gather accurate driver and vehicle information before requesting car insurance quotes.
- Compare policies with the same coverage limits, deductibles, and policy periods to understand price differences.
- Consider your state’s minimum requirements, your vehicle’s value, and any financing obligations when choosing coverage.
- Ask about available discounts and review payment terms before purchasing a policy.
- Make sure your new policy is active before canceling your existing coverage to avoid a lapse.
When Is the Best Time to Compare Car Insurance?
Car insurance rates and coverage needs can change over time, so it’s worth reviewing your options periodically. You may also want to compare quotes after a major life event or a change in your driving circumstances.
Some situations that may prompt a car insurance search include:
- When your teen driver gets their license: Adding a young driver may increase your premium, but some insurance companies offer good student or other eligible discounts.
- When you get married: Combining vehicles or policies with a spouse may create opportunities to review coverage and available discounts, although savings aren’t guaranteed.
- When you buy a home or move: Your location can affect your premium, and purchasing renters or homeowners insurance may make you eligible for a multi-policy discount.
- When your driving record changes: Tickets, accidents, or a DUI can affect your insurance options and rates, making it worthwhile to compare available policies.
- When you buy or finance a vehicle: A different vehicle or new loan may change the coverage you need.
You don’t have to wait until your policy expires to compare quotes. However, reviewing your options before renewal can give you time to evaluate coverage and coordinate any changes.
Step 1: Gather the Information You Need for Car Insurance Quotes
Having accurate information ready can make the quoting process easier and help you receive more reliable estimates.
Before shopping, gather the following:
- Vehicle information: Year, make, model, vehicle identification number (VIN), and estimated annual mileage.
- Driver information: Names, driver’s license details, and driving histories for drivers who need to be listed on the policy.
- Current insurance details: Your existing coverage limits, deductibles, and policy expiration date, if applicable.
- Vehicle use: Whether you use your vehicle for commuting, personal trips, or business-related driving.
- Address: The location where your primarily keep your vehicle.
Be accurate when providing information about your driving record, mileage, and vehicle use. Incorrect information can affect your final premium or create complications when purchasing coverage or filing a claim.
If you’re purchasing your first policy, understanding how to get insurance on a car can help you prepare for the process.
Step 2: Decide How You Want to Shop for Car Insurance
You can shop for car insurance online, over the phone, or with an insurance agent. Each approach has advantages, depending on how much assistance you want and whether you prefer comparing options independently.
Shopping for Car Insurance Online
Online shopping allows you to request quotes and review coverage options from your computer or phone. It can be convenient if you already understand your coverage needs and prefer managing the process yourself.
However, an initial online quote may change after the insurance company verifies your information. Reviewing the details before purchasing is important.
For drivers who prefer a digital experience, buying car insurance online can provide a convenient way to explore available options.
Shopping Through an Independent Agent or Broker
Independent agents and brokers may work with multiple insurance companies, allowing them to help you compare different policies.
This approach can be useful if you have questions about coverage, need help understanding policy differences, or have a driving history that limits your options.
The insurance companies available through an agent or broker depend on their business relationships. Ask which companies they represent and whether any fees apply.
Shopping Through an Exclusive Agent
An exclusive agent represents one insurance company and can explain that company’s coverage options, discounts, and policy features.
This approach may appeal to drivers who prefer working directly with a representative of a particular insurance company. However, you’ll need to request quotes elsewhere if you want to compare prices from multiple companies.
No single shopping method is right for everyone. Choose the approach that helps you understand your options and make an informed decision.
Step 3: Compare Car Insurance Quotes With the Same Coverage
One of the most important steps when shopping for car insurance is making sure you compare equivalent policies. A quote with lower liability limits or a higher deductible may cost less, but it may also provide less financial protection.
When you compare car insurance quotes, review the following details:
Policy Feature What to Compare Liability Limits Bodily injury and property damage coverage amounts Coverage Types Whether the policy includes collision, comprehensive, and other optional coverage Deductibles The amount you would pay toward a covered claim Premium The total cost of coverage for the policy period Policy Period Whether the quote covers six months, a year, or another term Payment Terms Down payment, installment amounts, and applicable fees You can also explore car insurance comparison options to understand what may be available.
Step 4: Choose the Right Car Insurance Coverage
The amount and type of coverage you need depend on your state’s requirements, your vehicle, and your financial situation.
Understanding the different types of car insurance coverage can help you decide which options to include in your quotes.
Liability Insurance
Liability insurance helps pay for covered injuries and property damage you cause to others in an accident, up to your policy limits.
Most states require drivers to maintain minimum liability coverage or another accepted form of financial responsibility. Requirements vary by state.
For example, California’s minimum auto liability insurance limits increased in 2025 to:
- Bodily injury liability: $30,000 per person/$60,000 per accident
- Property damage liability: $15,000 per accident
You can confirm the current requirements through the California DMV.
State minimum limits may not cover all expenses after a serious accident. Consider whether higher liability limits would provide more appropriate protection for your financial situation.
Collision and Comprehensive Coverage
Collision coverage can help pay for damage to your vehicle after a covered collision, subject to your deductible and policy terms. Comprehensive coverage can help pay for certain non-collision losses, such as theft, vandalism, fire, or weather-related damage. These coverages are typically optional under state insurance laws, but lenders or leasing companies may require them.
Full Coverage Car Insurance
Full coverage car insurance commonly refers to a policy that combines liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage. However, full coverage isn’t a standardized policy type, and it doesn’t mean every possible loss is covered. Review the actual coverages, limits, deductibles, and exclusions before purchasing.
You may also want to consider uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage, medical payments coverage, rental reimbursement, or roadside assistance, depending on your needs and what’s available. If you’re unfamiliar with insurance terminology, understanding car insurance basics can help you evaluate your options.
Step 5: Select Deductibles You Can Afford
A deductible is the amount you’re responsible for paying toward certain covered claims before your insurance coverage applies.
Choosing a higher deductible may lower your premium, while a lower deductible may increase it. Before making a decision, consider how much you could comfortably pay out of pocket if your vehicle needed repairs after an accident.
Step 6: Ask About Available Car Insurance Discounts
Insurance discounts may help reduce your premium, but eligibility varies by insurance company and state.
When requesting quotes, ask whether you qualify for any available car insurance discounts, such as:
- Multi-policy discounts
- Multi-vehicle discounts
- Good driver discounts
- Good student discounts
- Defensive driving course discounts
- Anti-theft device discounts
- Paperless billing or automatic payment discounts
- Paid-in-full discounts
- Low-mileage discounts
Some discounts may require documentation or have specific eligibility conditions. Ask which discounts are included in your quote and whether they continue at renewal. If affordability is your main concern, comparing cheap car insurance options can help you look for savings without overlooking important coverage.
Step 7: Evaluate Insurance Companies and Payment Terms
Price matters, but it shouldn’t be the only factor in your decision.
Consider how the insurance company handles claims, what customer support options are available, and whether the policy provides the coverage you need. You may also want to review customer feedback and complaint information from your state’s insurance department.
Before purchasing, confirm:
- The total premium for the policy period
- The amount due to start coverage
- Monthly installment amounts and applicable fees
- Available payment methods
- Cancellation terms and potential fees
- Whether the quoted coverage meets your needs
A policy with a lower initial payment isn’t necessarily the least expensive option overall. Check the full policy cost and payment schedule before deciding.
Step 8: Avoid a Coverage Lapse When Switching Policies
Once you’ve selected a new policy, make sure your coverage starts before canceling your existing insurance.
A car insurance lapse can leave you without financial protection while driving and may affect your future insurance options or premiums.
Before switching:
- Confirm your new policy has been approved and issued.
- Verify the effective date and time of your new coverage.
- Make any required initial payment.
- Cancel your previous policy only after confirming the new coverage is active.
- Keep copies of your new insurance documents.
If you’re canceling a policy before its expiration date, ask whether you’re eligible for a refund of unused premium and whether any cancellation fees apply.
Find Car Insurance That Fits Your Needs With Freeway
Finding the right car insurance involves understanding your coverage needs and reviewing the options available to you. Freeway Insurance can help you compare quotes and explore policies that fit your driving needs and budget.
Get a free car insurance quote online, call 800-777-5620, or find a Freeway Insurance office near you to explore your options.
Frequently Asked Questions About Shopping for Car Insurance
How Many Car Insurance Quotes Should I Compare?
Comparing quotes from several insurance companies can help you understand your options and identify potential price differences. Make sure each quote includes similar coverage limits, deductibles, and policy periods. Also review discounts, payment terms, and any additional fees. The lowest quote isn’t always the best fit if it provides less coverage than you need.
Is It Better to Shop for Car Insurance Online or Through an Agent?
Both methods can help you find car insurance, and the better choice depends on your preferences. Online shopping may be convenient if you’re comfortable reviewing coverage independently, while an agent can answer questions and explain policy differences. Some agents can also compare options from multiple insurance companies. Whichever method you choose, review the policy details before purchasing.
Can I Switch Car Insurance Companies Before My Policy Expires?
You can usually switch car insurance companies before your current policy expires. However, you should review any cancellation terms or fees before making the change. Confirm that your new policy is active before canceling your existing coverage to avoid a lapse.
Does Shopping for Car Insurance Affect My Credit Score?
Requesting car insurance quotes typically doesn’t affect your credit score because insurance-related credit checks generally use soft inquiries. However, some insurance companies use credit-based insurance information when determining rates, where permitted by state law. Other states restrict or prohibit the use of credit information for auto insurance pricing. Ask the insurance company how it evaluates your application if you have concerns about credit.
How Often Should I Shop for Car Insurance?
Reviewing your car insurance around renewal time can help you determine whether your current coverage and premium still meet your needs. It’s also worth comparing options after moving, buying a vehicle, adding a driver, or experiencing another significant change. Insurance prices and available discounts can change over time. Even if you decide to keep your current policy, reviewing your options can help you make a more informed decision.
Ready to Get a Quick Quote?
